Jump to content

Avatar

Take a setlist, and pick the best track, the worst track, and the most underrated track


  • Please log in to reply
10 replies to this topic

#1 VreyIsGrey

VreyIsGrey
  • 242 posts
  • Location
    Georgia, US

Posted May 20, 2020 - 04:24 PM

Exactly what it says on the tin. I've been inspired by a similar thread on RateYourMusic, but I thought this could carry over pretty well to a RB/GH setlist.

RB1
Best: Say It Ain't So
Worst: Celebrity Skin
Underrated: Timmy and the Lords of the Underworld

RB2
Best: Aqualung
Worst: Visions
Underrated: A Jagged Gorgeous Winter

RB3
Best: Llama
Worst: King George (this one was hard)
Underrated: Living in America

join the space_woosh fanclub
"Vrey's Custom Spreadsheet" - Spreadsheet containing every song I've put out on the database!
"Vrey's WIP Spreadsheet" - Spreadsheet full of every song I'm working on, so you know when I've started!


#2 YoshiIsDaBomb

YoshiIsDaBomb
  • 81 posts

Posted May 20, 2020 - 07:05 PM

RB1

Best: In Bloom

Worst: Celebrity Skin

Underrated: Next to You

 

RB2

Best: Drain You

Worst: Nine in the Afternoon

Underrated: Bodhisattva

 

RB3

Best: Plush

Worst: Oh My God

Underrated: In a Big Country

 

RB4

Best: Panama

Worst: I Bet My Life

Underrated: Hail to the King

 

LEGO

Best: Fire

Worst: Rooftops

Underrated: Crash

 

Blitz

Best: Cult of Personality

Worst: Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)

Underrated: Jungle Boogie

 

The only worst song that I mentioned that I hate is "I Bet My Life". Every other song is pretty okay or meh to me, but I feel like they are the weakest song for their respective game.

 

"Rooftops (A Liberation Broadcast)" is only on here because of obvious reasons

 

Guitar Hero Games (Ignoring the quality of the covers for GH1 to GH:Aerosmith)

 

GH1

Best: Stellar

Worst: Hey You

Underrated: Cheat on the Church

 

GH2

Best: John the Fisherman

Worst: Institutionalized

Underrated: Bad Reputation (Thin Lizzy)

 

GH80s

Best: Heat of the Moment

Worst: All of the songs are pretty good ngl

Underrated: Shakin'

 

GH3

Best: A tie between Mississippi Queen and Paranoid

Worst: Kool Thing

Underrated: Lay Down

 

GH:Aerosmith

  • Aerosmith songs
    • Best: Train Kept A-Rollin'
    • Worst: Pink
    • Underrated: Rats in the Cellar
  • Guest songs
    • Best: I Hate Myself for Loving You
    • Worst: Eh, all of the choices were good
    • Underrated: Personality Crisis

GH:WT

Best: Hot for Teacher

Worst: Rooftops

Underrated: Satch Boogie

 

GH:Metallica

  • Metallica songs
    • Best: Master of Puppets
    • Worst: Dyers Eve
    • Underrated: Battery
  • Guest songs
    • Best: Ace of Spades
    • Worst: Stacked Actors
    • Underrated: Am I Evil?

GH5

Best: Sex on Fire

Worst: All Along the Watchtower (Bob Dylan)

Underrated: Comedown

 

Band Hero

Best: Rio

Worst: The Taylor Swift songs

Underrated: If You Could Only See

 

GH:VH

  • Van Halen songs
    • Best: Little Guitars
    • Worst: ???
    • Underrated: Intruder/(Oh) Pretty Woman
  • Guest songs
    • Best: Painkiller
    • Worst: Most of them because they don't really fit with Van Halen's genre (none of them are really bad songs though)
    • Underrated: Space Truckin'

GH:WoR

Best: Burnin' for You (even though I don't like the re-recording)

Worst: Setting Fire to Sleeping Giants

Underrated: Children of the Grave

 

GH Live

Best: Won't Get Fooled Again

Worst: Bangarang

Underrated: Everybody Talks



#3 ambellina

ambellina
  • 2 posts

Posted May 20, 2020 - 08:12 PM

RB1
best: maps
worst: nightmare
underrated: outside

 

RB2
best: lazy eye
worst: livin on a prayer
underrated: de-luxe

 

L:RB
best: swing, swing
worst: rooftops
underrated: check yes juliet

 

TB:RB
best: while my guitar gently weeps
worst: boys
underrated: do u want to know a secret

 

GD:RB

best: basket case
worst: song of the century i guess
underrated: idk

 

RB3
best: just like heaven
worst: i love rock n roll
underrated: the con (2nd best!)

 

RB4
best: still into you
worst: i bet my life
underrated: dream genie  :)

 

GH3
best: fcpremix
worst: rock and roll all nite
underrated: helicopter

 

GHWT
best: l'via l'viaquez (even though its the radio edit!)
worst: rooftops again by default, or stranglehold
underrated: obstacle 1

 

GHM
best: demon cleaner
worst: tuesday's gone
underrated: also demon cleaner i guess?

 

GH5
best: 21st century schizoid man
worst: hurts so good
underrated: seven

 

BH
best: ocean avenue
worst: lips of an angel
underrated: les artistes

 

GHVH
best: pain
worst: all the actual van halen songs lol
underrated: ? end of heartache i guess ???

 

GHWOR
best: i'm not okay (i promise)
worst: hard to see
underrated: there's no secrets this year



#4 lifeismusic5

lifeismusic5
  • 481 posts

Posted May 20, 2020 - 08:15 PM

RB1
Best: Coheed & Cambria - Welcome Home
Worst: Maps - Yeah Yeah Yeah
Underrated: Stone Temple Pilots - Vaseline

RB2
Best: Dream Theater - Panic Attack
Worst: Abnormality - Visions
Underrated: a toss up between
The Muffs - Kids in America & Jethro Tull - Aqualung

LegoRB
Best: The Primitives - Crash
Worst: Supergrass - Grace
Underrated: Kaiser Chiefs - Ruby

GDRB
Best: Jesus of Suburbia or Letterbomb
Worst: Song of the Century
Underrated: Before The Lobotomy

BeatlesRB
Best: Day Tripper
Worst: Yellow Submarine
Underrated: Hey Bulldog

RB3
Best: Chicago - 25 or 6 to 4
Worst: Maná - Oye Mi Amor
Underrated: Faith No More - Midlife Crisis

RB4
Best: Outfield - Your Love
Worst: Imagine Dragons - I Bet My Life
Underrated: Mighty Mighty Bosstones - Impression That I Get

GH
Best: Helmet - Unsung
Worst: Joan Jett - I Love Rock N Roll
Underrated: The Exies - Hey You

GH2
Best: Foo Fighters - Monkey Wrench
Worst: The Pretenders - Tattooed Love Boys
Underrated: Spinal Tap - Tonight Im Gonna Rock You Tonight

GH3
Best: Living Colour - Cult of Personality
Worst: Bloc Party - Helicopter or Gallows - In The Belly of a Shark
Underrated: Rise Against - Prayer of the Refugee

GHA
Best: The Black Crows - Hard To Handle
Best A: Mama Kin
Worst: The Clash - Complete Control
Worst A: Anything from Joe Perry
Underrated: Stone Temple Pilots - Sex Type Thing
Underrated A: No Surprize

GHRT80s
Best: 38. Special - Hold on Loosely or Poison - Nothin but a Good Time
Worst: X - Los Angeles
Underrated: Iron Maiden - Wrathchild or Oingo Boingo - Only A Lad

GHWT
Best: Dream Theater - Pull Me Under
Worst: Interpol - Obstacle 1
Underrated: Sting - Demolition Man

GH5
Best: Grand Funk Railroad - Were An American Band
Worst: Vampire Weekend - A-Punk
Underrated: A Perfect Circle - Judith

GHVH
Best: Weezer - Dope Nose or Foreigner - Double Vision
Best VH: Dance The Night Away
Worst: The Clash - Safe European Home
Worst VH: Atomic Punk
Underrated: Foo Fighters - Best Of You
Underrated VH: Im the One

GHM
Best: Lynyrd Skynyrd - Tuesdays Gone
Best M: Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
Worst: Queen - Stone Cold Crazy
Worst M: Nothing Else Matters (too slow & easy)
Underrated: Alice In Chains - No Excuses
Underrated M: Whiplash

BH:
Best: Snow Patrol - Take Back The City
Worst: either Joss Stone - You Had Me or Duffy - Warwick Avenue
Underrated: Dashboard Confessional - Hands Down

GHWoR
Best: Styx - Renegade or Anthrax - Indians
Worst: Nickelback - How You Remind Me
Underrated: Queensrÿche - Jet City Woman

#5 Dangus

Dangus
  • 540 posts
  • Location
    IL

Posted May 20, 2020 - 08:18 PM

RB1

Best: Highway Star

Worst: 29 Fingers (awful song)

Underrated: Day Late, Dollar Short (somehow I love this song but I do lol)

 

RB2

Best: Girl's Not Grey

Worst: A Tie Between... Mountain Song And Drain You (hate most of songs by both of these bands)

Underrated: Pretend We're Dead

 

RB3

Best: Just Like Heaven Or Space Oddity

Worst: Oh My God or Oye Mi Amor (can't stand either one)

Underrated: Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots Pt. 1

 

RB4

Best: Friday I'm In Love

Worst: I Bet My Life or Recession (hate both)

Underrated: Albert

 

LEGO

Best: Crash

Worst: Short and Sweet (instrumentally it's good, but can't stand the song.)

Underrated: Make Me Smile (Come Up and See Me)

 

Blitz

Best: Death on Two Legs (Dedicated To...)

Worst: Jungle Boogie

Underrated: Death on Two Legs (Dedicated To...)



#6 Meta123

Meta123
  • 34 posts

Posted May 20, 2020 - 08:43 PM

note: i used more than one song in some categories because i felt wrong not shouting out some of these
 
rock band games
 
rb1:
best - cherub rock / maps
worst - nightmare
underrated - main offender
 
rb2:
best - lazy eye / pda
worst - let there be rock / shooting star / livin' on a prayer
underrated - teen age riot / de-luxe / a jagged gorgeous winter
 
tbrb:
best - i want you (she's so heavy) / helter skelter 
worst - yellow submarine 
underrated - idk if i'd call any of these songs underrated but hey bulldog can go here
 
lrb:
best - naive / every little thing she does is magic
worst - walking on sunshine / you give love a bad name / the final countdown (and morally speaking rooftops)
underrated - crash / check yes juliet
 
gdrb:
best - welcome to paradise
worst - i'm not super familiar with a lot of these songs but are we the waiting/st. jimmy is pretty bad
underrated - brain stew/jaded i guess
 
rb3:
best - the killing moon / just like heaven
worst - outer space / sister christian
underrated - the con / oh my god / one armed scissor (is one armed scissor really underrated though?)
 
rbb:
best - shout 
worst - diamond eyes (boom-lay boom-lay boom) / bang your head (metal health)
underrated - pumped up kicks
 
rb4: 
best - dream genie
worst - free falling
underrated - dream genie again cause this song gets WAY too much hate
 
guitar hero games
 
gh1:
best - take me out maybe
worst - probably eureka, i've found love
underrated - even rats
 
gh2:
best - crazy on you / war pigs
worst - cherry pie (and probably some random bonus song)
underrated - elephant bones / freya
 
gh80s:
best - los angeles / i ran (so far away)
worst - pretty much the rest of the setlist with a few exceptions lol
underrated - police truck i guess
 
gh3: 
best - cherub rock / helicopter
worst - down and dirty
underrated - fcpremix / kool thing
 
gha:
best - nope
worst - every song sucks
underrated - maybe except for all day and all of the night and kings and queens
 
ghwt:
best - lazy eye / obstacle 1 (hey it looks like rb2 had a similar lineup)
worst - the joker / too much, too young, too fast / hotel california / livin' on a prayer (and once again rooftops for moral reasons)
underrated: toy boy / shiver / l'via l'viaquez / one armed scissor (same question as i had for rb3)
 
ghm:
best - i don't like or care about this setlist but um welcome home (sanitarium) maybe
worst - most of the game could go here but i'm just gonna single out enter sandman
underrated - maybe like demon cleaner 
 
ghsh:
best - wow this setlist sucks too uhhh freya and take me out sure
worst - cherry pie once again
underrated - no one knows it's not underrated i just have nothing else to put here
 
gh5: 
best - seven / 21st century schizoid man
worst - why bother? / you give love a bad name (probably, half of this setlist i don't remember) oh sneak out sucks too
underrated - bleed american and brianstorm both go stupid hard
 
bh:
best - ocean avenue / the impression that i get (aaaaaaaaaaaaa)
worst - walking on sunshine takes the cake once again but lips of an angel sucks really hard too
underrated - naive can go here even though it probably belongs in the best tier
 
ghvh:
best - damn this game sucks
worst - damn this game REALLY sucks
underrated - like pain and sick sick sick are the only songs worth mentioning this game really sucks
 
ghwor:
best - fascination street
worst - unskinny bop / pour some sugar on me (live)
underrated - it's only another parsec...
 


#7 PikedPike

PikedPike
  • 39 posts
  • Location
    Australia

Posted May 21, 2020 - 12:06 AM

Have not played guitar hero in forever, and barely touched 4 lol, will just do the main 3 and LEGO

RB1

Best: Highway Star - Deep Purple
Worst: New Wave - Pleymo (or for those without European, Train Kept A-Rollin - [as made famous by] Aerosmith
Underrated: Electric Version - The New Pornographers

 

RB2

Best: That's What You Get - Paramore

Worst: Visions - Abnormality
Underrated: New Kid In School - The Donnas

RB3

 

Best: The Con - Tegan And Sara
Worst: Hey Man, Nice Shot - Filter
Underrated: Viva La Resistance - Hypernova

LEGO

Best: Swing Swing - AAR
Worst: Rooftops - Lost Prophets (tho probably in reality it is Ride A White Swan - T.Rex)
Underrated: Monster - The Automatic


I beat Roundabout on Keyboard Once, that means I am good right?
Also if you pro keys 2 hands, you a cheater, just saying.


#8 EchoOfMystery

EchoOfMystery
  • 201 posts
  • Location
    Brazil

Posted May 21, 2020 - 01:11 PM

Haven't played all RB or GH games, so I'll stick to the ones I know.

 

RB

Best: Black Hole Sun

Worst: 29 Fingers

Underrated: Outside

 

RB2

Best: The Trees (Vault Edition)

Worst: You Outta Know

Underrated: Any Way You Want It

 

RB3

Best: The Killing Moon

Worst: Get Up, Stand Up

Underrated: Portions for Foxes

 

GH2

Best: YYZ

Worst: Institutionalized

Underrated: Can't You Hear Me Knockin'

 

GH3

Best: Cliffs of Dover

Worst: Generation Rock

Underrated: Avalancha

 

GHWT

Best: Lazy Eye

Worst: Monsoon

Underrated: Band on the Run

 

GH5

Best: Sultans Of Swing

Worst: Bring the Noise 20XX

Underrated: All the Pretty Faces

 

GHWoR

Best: 2112

Worst: Pour Some Sugar on Me (Live)

Underrated: Slow Hands



#9 drummerockband

drummerockband

    I Charted Tegan and Sara and All I Got Was This Crappy Title

  • 818 posts
  • Location
    Ontario, Canada

Posted May 21, 2020 - 02:47 PM

RB1

Best: Foreplay/Longtime

Worst: 29 Fingers

Underrated: Sabotage

 

RB2

Best: That's What You Get

Worst: Rebel Girl

Underrated: Alex Chilton

 

RB3

Best: The Con

Worst: Me Enamora

Underrated: Antibodies

 

RB4:

Best: You Make Loving Fun

Worst: Milwaukee

Underrated: The Warrior

 

Rock Band Blitz:

Best: Jessie's Girl

Worst: We Are Young

Underrated: Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)

 

LEGO:

Best: A-Punk

Worst: Rooftops

Underrated: Make Me Smile (Come Up and See Me)

 

Band Hero (because its my favourite GH game sue me):

Best: Like Whoa/So Yesterday/Taylor Swift songs

Worst: Rock Star

Underrated: L.E.S. Artistes


My Customs | Featuring customs from Disney movies, "Weird Al" Yankovic, Tegan and Sara, Alvvays and more!


#10 FUGGNUTZ

FUGGNUTZ
  • 128 posts
  • Location
    St. Louis

Posted May 22, 2020 - 12:06 AM

RB1

Best: Gimme Shelter

Worst: Nightmare

Underrated: Epic

 

RB2

Best: Everlong

Worst: Conventional Lover

Underrated: Our Truth

 

RB3

Best: In a Big Country

Worst: King George

Underrated: Don't Bury Me... I'm Still Not Dead

 

RB4

Best: The Impression That I Get

Worst: Light Up the Night

Underrated: Ain't Messin' Round

 

LEGO

Best: I Want You Back

Worst: Kung Fu Fighting

Underrated: Crash

 

Guitar Hero Games (Ignoring the quality of the covers for GH1 to GH:Aerosmith)

 

GH1

Best: Stellar

Worst: The Breaking Wheel

Underrated: Even Rats

 

GH2

Best: Killing in the Name

Worst: Yes We Can

Underrated: Girlfriend

 

GH80s

Best: Synchronicity II

Worst: Balls to the Wall

Underrated: Only A Lad

 

GH3

Best: Bulls On Parade

Worst: Go That Far

Underrated: Don't Hold Back

 

GH:WT

Best: Everlong

Worst: Never Too Late

Underrated: L'Via L'Viaquez

 

GH:WoR

Best: Holy Wars... The Punishment Due

Worst: Ravenous

Underrated: Graduate



#11 VreyIsGrey

VreyIsGrey
  • 242 posts
  • Location
    Georgia, US

Posted June 28, 2020 - 01:44 PM

LEGO
Best: Breakout (so many equally good ones, this was hard to pick)
Worst: Rooftops (for obvious reasons)
Underrated: Monster

join the space_woosh fanclub
"Vrey's Custom Spreadsheet" - Spreadsheet containing every song I've put out on the database!
"Vrey's WIP Spreadsheet" - Spreadsheet full of every song I'm working on, so you know when I've started!





1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users