22 replies to this topic

[DashRetro]

 

What's the fun in that? I don't sing just to hum consistent tones until I finish the song. It's like asking why bother making any instruments more than zero dots because you can just get a bot to play it for you.

 

As far as actually tiering them sometimes you come across a song that takes more than just pitch to do well in. I would not consider a song like "Rap God" to be a zero dot song...if I'm actually singing, that is.

 

This is a topic I've thought about a lot.  Not even just rap, all death metal is 0 dots, but can you actually sing like that?

 

I feel like the difficulty of certain songs when you're trying to be authentic isn't done justice by the "talkies are 0 dots" rating system, HOWEVER, I think it's way too big a can of worms to get into the even more subjective debate about how to go about scoring them differently.

[lifeismusic5]

 
This is a topic I've thought about a lot.  Not even just rap, all death metal is 0 dots, but can you actually sing like that?
 
I feel like the difficulty of certain songs when you're trying to be authentic isn't done justice by the "talkies are 0 dots" rating system, HOWEVER, I think it's way too big a can of worms to get into the even more subjective debate about how to go about scoring them differently.

I cant, thats for sure. Its very hard to quote sing unquote death metal let alone growl death metal. Ive most certainly tried, a song like Visions on Rock Band 2 is one of those songs unless you have the right growl its just not gonna happen lol

[DashRetro]

I can hit a Necrophagist growl for like 10 seconds before my throat is jacked and I'm chugging water for the rest of the day.