Jump to content

  • GoodGooglyMoogly likes this
Avatar

Interpol - "Public Pervert"


Interpol Public Pervert

Release Type: User
Audio Type: Single-track
Reductions: Yes (Auto/CAT)
Pitched Vocals: Yes
Vocals Gender: Male (1)

Band:
Guitar:
Drums:
Vocals:
Bass:
Keys:
Pro Keys:
Pro Guitar:
Pro Bass:

Author Notes

[25/10/17]: Fixed previously missing blue and yellow notes in drums.
[17/10/17]: Fixed separated syllables near end of sung section.



4 Comments

Avatar
GoodGooglyMoogly
October 25, 2017

I noticed a missing blue cymbal around the lyric "but some get faith before they die" near the start (~4:07 left on track).  Unless that's the fix you posted.

 

Also the open hi hat charting seems to be pretty inconsistent.  It seems like you skip charting the opens as blue during faster sections but chart open as blue during the slower parts.  Almost everyone charts open hi hats as blue consistently throughout, so it throws me off a bit.  I was kind of hoping songs like The New you would chart all opens as blue as well.

 

(All constructive criticism, love the tracks!)

Avatar
EchoOfMystery
October 25, 2017
Ah! Thank you for pointing out the missing perc note!
 
Now about the hi-hats, idk if the way I do it is utterly wrong but, bear with me:
It's like you said, yes, I don't chart open hi-hats on blue in fast parts, but only if there's a disco section going on OR the hit is close to a drum fill that contains blue notes. Ironically, I thought it could make the chart less difficult/confusing, since I've seen it happen sometimes in main songs. Also, since I don't like charting flipped disco, in some cases one would have to hit the blue pad with the left hand - depending on the song speed and drum setup, it would be very obnoxious... I'm sure there must be people who hit the snare in disco sections with the left hand, as well. I used to. lol
 
Thank you for the feedback! Wanna be my Interpol songs critic? :D
Avatar
GoodGooglyMoogly
October 25, 2017

Personally I have 2 cymbals setup as blue (a small one above my yellow cymbal and one on the right next to my green) so I don't find it difficult to hit all the open hi hats as blue even in fast sections.  I know that's not the case for everyone, but as far as Rock Band goes I believe they almost always chart open hi hat as blue (unless all notes are open) so I just got used to that being the case.  I've even seen (in rare cases) some people use a second pedal with a switch so that when they let off their hi hat pedal it triggers blue instead of yellow.

 

The video you posted is actually the short version which doesn't include the open hi-hats I was referring to, but all of the faster ones in that song (I believe) are with the right hand, so I don't think it would be too confusing.  Either way, I understand where you're coming from I just figured I'd give you my opinion on that.

 

I'd be happy to critique your Interpol songs (at least on drums). I haven't had a chance to play through all of them yet.  I'm just excited someone is finally charting all of these after waiting YEARS for any Interpol.  :)

Avatar
EchoOfMystery
October 25, 2017

Awesome! :D I would have put a better video in there but there's some lame country restriction for Brazil, and that seemed to be the best I could find. lol