Jump to content

  • Sideshow, AJFOne23, rcale and 4 others like this
Avatar

The Beatles - "Not Guilty"


The Beatles Not Guilty

Release Type: User
Audio Type: Single-track
Reductions: Yes (Authored)
Pitched Vocals: Yes
Vocals Gender: Male (1)

Band:
Guitar:
Drums:
Vocals:
Bass:
Keys:
Pro Keys:
Pro Guitar:
Pro Bass:

Author Notes

In 1967 George Harrison was deep into Eastern music and philosophy. With their touring days over, George suggested that the Beatles take a 3 month trip to India to relax, rejuvenate, and study Transcendental Meditation with Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. 
 
Spiritually, the trip was not a huge success. Ringo left in less than 2 weeks because the food did not agree with him. Paul left midway through the trip, being followed by John and George about a month before the trip was scheduled to end. Allegations of inappropriate relationships between the Maharishi and some female students contributed to their early departure and is the basis for John's song Sexy Sadie (which was originally sung as "Maharishi, what have you done?"). The allegations proved untrue. 
 
Musically, the trip allowed the Beatles the time to experiment acoustically and compose vast quantities of new songs. Not Guilty was one of 26 songs demoed upon their return to England, and with a few additions and subtractions these comprised their next self-titled album, commonly called the White Album due to is stark album "art". 
 
Not Guilty was recorded and ready to be included on the album, but with too much material to even fit on a double album, cuts were made. Not Guilty was the last song to be cut before the track listing was finalized. Perhaps the Beatles were not entirely pleased with how it turned out - it was tricky to record with multiple time signature changes.
 
Historically, George was also only given 1-2 songs per album, and even though he was now rivalling Lennon and McCartney as a songwriter, old habits die hard and he only ended up with 4 songs on the double album. Serious fractures were also beginning to form within the group (Ringo quit the band at one point during recording of the album - the first Beatle to do so) and this song's topic may have been a sore point. Lyrically, George is washing his hands of responsibility for the less-than-successful India trip. Perhaps the Beatles did not wish to air their dirty laundry on the record.
 
This full length of take 102, running 4:28, is the remastered version from the Super Deluxe 50th anniversary release. A shortened version of the song (cutting the guitar solo amongst other things)  appeared on Anthology 3 running 3:22. George would ultimately re-record an acoustic version of the song for his 1978 self titled solo album, but I much prefer the treatment the Beatles gave it. 



7 Comments

Avatar
bloosmurf
June 12, 2019

I decided to not include the vocal "noises" George does toward the end of the song. It's a lot of "cha" "sha" and "clicks". I tried playing with these in the chart and many of them are barely audible. Perhaps if you were singing without also playing an instrument it would be interesting. But when playing and singing, it was nearly impossible to get them. It made the song (which is already somewhat obscure) way less fun to play.

 

If people are interested in a version with those vocalizations in place, I can certainly make that available.

Avatar
mcgg38
June 12, 2019

Thank you, bloosmurf, for this Beatles rarity! There's always room for more Beatles :D

Avatar
yaniv297
June 13, 2019

Wow here's a song I've never expected. Thanks!

Avatar
Mandrag
June 13, 2019

Great choice and Beatles is so welcome :)

Avatar
bloosmurf
June 13, 2019

Wow here's a song I've never expected. Thanks!

 

If you're looking for obscure Beatles material, I'm your guy. 

 

I'd love to do some other Beatles rarities in the future: What's the New Mary Jane, If You've Got Trouble, That Means a Lot, and maybe even Sour Milk Sea or 12-Bar Original. Actually I might tackle Yer Blues by the Dirty Mac next. I'm kind of a Beatles nut. At my current skill level, I might need some help with harmonies if I can't find anything to reference. 

 

On the other hand, I could always lend a hand to the Anthology project (assuming it's still chugging along). 

I might need some help with the harmonies. 

Would you be willing to chart their cover of Shout

Avatar
fakedrummer89
October 3, 2019

drum chart needs lots of work