Jump to content

Avatar

Blink-182 - "Man Overboard"


Blink-182 Man Overboard

Release Type: User
Audio Type: Single-track
Reductions: No
Pitched Vocals: (no vocals)

Band:
Guitar:
Drums:
Vocals:
Bass:
Keys:
Pro Keys:
Pro Guitar:
Pro Bass:


8 Comments

Avatar
grubextrapolate
June 30, 2020

why are you uploading a drum-only expert-only chart for a song that already has full band+difficulties in the db? http://customscreato...verboard-r24248

Avatar
Joshwantsmaccas
June 30, 2020

why are you uploading a drum-only expert-only chart for a song that already has full band+difficulties in the db? http://customscreato...verboard-r24248

By the looks of it hes uploading their entire collection they have done. There's nothing really wrong with doing so, maybe he things hes chart for drums is better? (just a guess)

Avatar
grubextrapolate
June 30, 2020

By the looks of it hes uploading their entire collection they have done. There's nothing really wrong with doing so, maybe he things hes chart for drums is better? (just a guess)

sure, it's allowed, but at least frowned upon. if there was an issue with the original chart, normally you'd work with the author to improve it - either by providing feedback or offering to update the chart. going this route you get to have one excellent and full chart as opposed to one that's very incomplete and another that (possibly) has an issue. I asked as I'd at least hope they'd reached out to DemonUnicorns to try and work together. perhaps the two did not agree on a solution and they remained separate - which is the case you mention - but perhaps this author wasn't aware of the other or that this is the standard practice. normally if it were the former and they agreed on separate charts, you'd tag the post to indicate this and avoid questions. just asking as i'd always hope folks work together to have a single amazing version of a chart rather than several different incomplete/incorrect ones.

Avatar
Joshwantsmaccas
June 30, 2020
Nahh that's fair. I getcha.
Avatar
hardcoredrummer
June 30, 2020

sure, it's allowed, but at least frowned upon. if there was an issue with the original chart, normally you'd work with the author to improve it - either by providing feedback or offering to update the chart. going this route you get to have one excellent and full chart as opposed to one that's very incomplete and another that (possibly) has an issue. I asked as I'd at least hope they'd reached out to DemonUnicorns to try and work together. perhaps the two did not agree on a solution and they remained separate - which is the case you mention - but perhaps this author wasn't aware of the other or that this is the standard practice. normally if it were the former and they agreed on separate charts, you'd tag the post to indicate this and avoid questions. just asking as i'd always hope folks work together to have a single amazing version of a chart rather than several different incomplete/incorrect ones.

i agree with this but not everyone seems to want to chart the most complete correct version. let alone let someone else and upload it even if credit is given...i've seen songs where the drum machine is charted and not the live drums and that's that. they don't want the other version made etc. so i get doing corrections yourself but i would just think you would keep that to yourself and not repost. suppose it's also different if you take a full band chart and just change the drums vs uploading a track of drums only. i just don't see anyone downloading this version even if the drums are better. i'm interested to check it out but i played unicorns and probably even bugged him if i thought something was off....lol joking but he does good work and i think his chart was pretty accurate...i remember actually waiting for man overboard when we spoke...if this track is a problem will the mods remove it?

Avatar
Joshwantsmaccas
July 1, 2020

i agree with this but not everyone seems to want to chart the most complete correct version. let alone let someone else and upload it even if credit is given...i've seen songs where the drum machine is charted and not the live drums and that's that. they don't want the other version made etc. so i get doing corrections yourself but i would just think you would keep that to yourself and not repost. suppose it's also different if you take a full band chart and just change the drums vs uploading a track of drums only. i just don't see anyone downloading this version even if the drums are better. i'm interested to check it out but i played unicorns and probably even bugged him if i thought something was off....lol joking but he does good work and i think his chart was pretty accurate...i remember actually waiting for man overboard when we spoke...if this track is a problem will the mods remove it.

I don't think it'll get removed coz there's countless double up on the database. The best thing is if with double ups both have videos, you can check them out before downloading and work out which chart looks more fun to you. That's what I do, so if I prefer one that's got just drums, I'll usually just grab that one because drumming is my main instrument but i'm sure not everyone would do that.

Avatar
BrianTD9192
July 1, 2020

why are you uploading a drum-only expert-only chart for a song that already has full band+difficulties in the db? http://customscreato...verboard-r24248

 

I don't think it'll get removed coz there's countless double up on the database. The best thing is if with double ups both have videos, you can check them out before downloading and work out which chart looks more fun to you. That's what I do, so if I prefer one that's got just drums, I'll usually just grab that one because drumming is my main instrument but i'm sure not everyone would do that.

Hello everyone! Im sure you noticed it but i started uploading all of my best charts that i made in the past (and i have many of those) so im not really checking out if some of those are already existings on this site. Btw i didn't know about a full band chart of Man Overboard and it's weird as i enjoy Blink-182 quite a lot and i thought i already had all of theyr available charts. 

So, if you want me to delete some of my customs as there's a better/more complete version already, it's not a problem for me, i have no more charts from this band to upload anyways.

Avatar
hardcoredrummer
July 1, 2020

yeah videos are nice. have you compared this one already?